Continuity errors between the game and comic
0
posted04/21/2015 12:27 AM (UTC)by
Avatar
residentfan
Avatar
Member Since
03/04/2015 01:05 AM (UTC)
So, I believe everyone noticed some errors between the game and comic, here are a few I found:

Jacqui throught Outworld's sky would be purple, but she visited this realm before and knew this wasn't true.

Erron Black doesn't remenber of Cassie and Jacqui in the Story Mode.

Kotal Kahn is smarter in the comics.

Sonya is more hostile in the comics than in the game.

The game has diferent time periods than in the comics, the comics happen 15 years after MK9, but Sonya's bio says that she and Johnny split 20 years after MK9 while they are already split in the comics.

Scorpion's smarter in the comics.

No mention on what Goro is doing in the game.

Rain is perfectly healthy in the game, even after being nearly killed by Kotal.

No mention of neither Havik or Reino.

No mention on how Frost ended on the Lin Kuei.

Have I forgot something?
Scorpion seems about as shortsighted in both. Also, Outworld's sky IS purple in a lot of areas. The hell were they talking about?
Avatar
SaltyRice
04/17/2015 01:13 AM (UTC)
0
Another one is that Takeda never was at the Sky Temple and the temple is located between realms.

In the comics Takeda travels with Scorpion per foot to the Sky Temple.
Avatar
Sekktor
Avatar
About Me

04/17/2015 01:27 AM (UTC)
0
the comics aren't canon, at all. no relative to the MKX game whatsoever.
Avatar
T0asty
Avatar
About Me

art by blacksaibot

04/17/2015 01:29 AM (UTC)
0
TigerStyle Wrote:
Scorpion seems about as shortsighted in both. Also, Outworld's sky IS purple in a lot of areas. The hell were they talking about?


Yeah what is up with that? Outworld used to be very purple and I liked that because it added a bit of surrealism and the since of otherworldiness to outworld. Now Outworld is just the middle east or something lol.
Avatar
lanoitarnu
Avatar
About Me

What

04/17/2015 01:31 AM (UTC)
0
T0asty Wrote:
TigerStyle Wrote:
Scorpion seems about as shortsighted in both. Also, Outworld's sky IS purple in a lot of areas. The hell were they talking about?


Yeah what is up with that? Outworld used to be very purple and I liked that because it added a bit of surrealism and the since of otherworldiness to outworld. Now Outworld is just the middle east or something lol.


I'm fine with the area of Outworld we see being sort of middle eastish because Outworld is a bunch of realms merged together so I think one part could look like it does in Mkx and another part with the purple sky and living forests.
Avatar
lanoitarnu
Avatar
About Me

What

04/17/2015 01:33 AM (UTC)
0
I do wish we had one outworld stage with the purple sky though.
Avatar
mkmileena
Avatar
About Me

Ethereal, ravenous, piercing. It's Mileena bitch.

Lovely signature by MINION

04/17/2015 01:39 AM (UTC)
0
Sekktor Wrote:
the comics aren't canon, at all. no relative to the MKX game whatsoever.


I thought it was confirmed they were.
Avatar
KenshiMaster16
04/17/2015 01:42 AM (UTC)
0
mkmileena Wrote:
Sekktor Wrote:
the comics aren't canon, at all. no relative to the MKX game whatsoever.


I thought it was confirmed they were.


It was. Errors are just errors. Most multi-media franchises have problems with keeping continuity.
Avatar
Sekktor
Avatar
About Me

04/17/2015 01:43 AM (UTC)
0
KenshiMaster16 Wrote:
mkmileena Wrote:
Sekktor Wrote:
the comics aren't canon, at all. no relative to the MKX game whatsoever.


I thought it was confirmed they were.


It was. Errors are just errors. Most multi-media franchises have problems with keeping continuity.


Oh. My mistake then
Avatar
Blade4693
04/17/2015 01:44 AM (UTC)
0
mkmileena Wrote:
Sekktor Wrote:
the comics aren't canon, at all. no relative to the MKX game whatsoever.


I thought it was confirmed they were.


According to Ed Boon, they are canon.

As for the sky being purple thing, it is in some places, like the Wasteland for example. I'm sure that's just ignorance on Kung Jin's part (Even if he is well knowledgeable when it comes to Outworld)
Avatar
KenshiMaster16
04/17/2015 01:54 AM (UTC)
0
Sekktor Wrote:
KenshiMaster16 Wrote:
mkmileena Wrote:
Sekktor Wrote:
the comics aren't canon, at all. no relative to the MKX game whatsoever.


I thought it was confirmed they were.


It was. Errors are just errors. Most multi-media franchises have problems with keeping continuity.


Oh. My mistake then


No biggie. smile
Avatar
Sockie
04/17/2015 02:06 AM (UTC)
0
residentfan Wrote:
So, I believe everyone noticed some errors between the game and comic, here are a few I found:

Jacqui throught Outworld's sky would be purple, but she visited this realm before and knew this wasn't true.

Erron Black doesn't remenber of Cassie and Jacqui in the Story Mode.

Kotal Kahn is smarter in the comics.

Sonya is more hostile in the comics than in the game.

The game has diferent time periods than in the comics, the comics happen 15 years after MK9, but Sonya's bio says that she and Johnny split 20 years after MK9 while they are already split in the comics.

Scorpion's smarter in the comics.

No mention on what Goro is doing in the game.

Rain is perfectly healthy in the game, even after being nearly killed by Kotal.

No mention of neither Havik or Reino.

No mention on how Frost ended on the Lin Kuei.

Have I forgot something?


There was no indication Erron didn't remember them, either. He wanted to know what their business was in Outworld, not who they were.

I don't see how slightly different characterization is a continuity error. You're going to get that with different writers. This goes for Kotal, Sonya, and Scorpion, and it's pretty arguable how different they actually are--the comics' characterization is definitely based off of the game's from where I'm standing.

Maybe they just didn't officially divorce until 5 years before the game?

How are Goro, Havik, Reiko, and Frost not being mentioned continuity errors of any kind? What reason would there have been for mentioning them, or for telling how Frost ended up in the Lin Kuei? Do you really think Scorpion would have been interested in hearing Frost's entire life story? The comic will tell us that, and characters not just standing around and talking about where every other character is isn't an error in any way.

It's been 10 years since Rain got fried, and he's a demi-god. I think it's within the realm of possibility that he healed nicely.
Avatar
shrairyuwarrior
Avatar
About Me

PSN:athlos23

04/17/2015 02:08 AM (UTC)
0
Resident fan they dis mention reiko. When they said the reiko accords. But you are right Havik wasn't mentioned. Probably because he isn't important to shinnoks story
Avatar
Cages_Shades
Avatar
About Me
Props to MINION
04/17/2015 02:58 AM (UTC)
0
The comics ARE canon, BUT the games story was made first

Its the comics writers fault not NRS, but i'm sure the comic writers didnt know every dialogue of the game.
Avatar
BiohazardEXTREME
04/17/2015 05:25 AM (UTC)
0
Regarding not mentioning Reiko or Havik, you gotta remember, some people won't be reading the comics. If they just happened to drop their names like something important happened, and that's it, that would only confuse the people who didn't read the comics, not to mention it would've added unnecessary dialogue, which costs money, right?
Heck even them mentioning the "Reiko Accords" in the game, I mean, I read the comics, so I know that Reiko plays a part in Mileena's backstory, but if I hadn't, I'd be pretty confused about why his name is brought up at all.

The comics may be cannon, but they're still their own entity. I was actually pleasantly surprised that the plot of the game had nothing to do with the central plot of the comic. I think it was a very smart move, because that way, the comic isn't just some tertiary counterpart to the game, that's there to supplement the plot or serve as a promotional gimmick for the game itself. Whatever is going on with Mileena and Reiko in the comics, and the whole Havik and the Kamidogu Blood Kode business is a completely different story arc, and something to look forward to in the comics themselves. Hopefully, it will allow the MKX comics to become an ongoing thing even through the next MK game.
Avatar
Gillbob316
04/17/2015 06:23 PM (UTC)
0
How in God's name has no one mentioned the fact that Kotal Kahn and all Osh-tekk are blue/green in the comics, But in the game Kotal is flesh colored in the past and only turns blue in some unexplained manner after becoming emperor.

Furthermore Kotal's guards are themselves referred to as Osh-tekk in the mobile game, and are also flesh colored, but since all Osh-tekk are supposed to be dead, that also makes little to no sense.

I feel like they probably weren't supposed to be blue in the first place, and Kotal was supposed to have turned blue after using the dagger to invoke the blood god power... But they likely screwed up in the translation, so instead it's just a big ball of errors.

Also, Goro's ending implies he's alive and well with all his arms after Shinnok's fall. I realize endings aren't always solid canon, but I feel like his presence in the game alone at least half heartedly implies he's around in present day (ish) so while it isn't a plot hole per say... it is one of the more glaring things lacking explanation.
Avatar
frabn
Avatar
About Me

Well, you all got your Tremor now. Can we finally move on?

04/17/2015 07:54 PM (UTC)
0
Simple - Comic has nothing to do with the game. It's a standalone story using MKX characters, but it has no tie-in to the game at all. The only consistencies are the character set-ups (Scorpion/Takeda/Kenshi). The actual events of the comic are irrelevant. I realized that by the time I was at Chapter 3, and now have no interest in reading the comic any longer.

Avatar
MartyKirra
04/18/2015 08:51 AM (UTC)
0
Gillbob316 Wrote:
How in God's name has no one mentioned the fact that Kotal Kahn and all Osh-tekk are blue/green in the comics, But in the game Kotal is flesh colored in the past and only turns blue in some unexplained manner after becoming emperor.

Furthermore Kotal's guards are themselves referred to as Osh-tekk in the mobile game, and are also flesh colored, but since all Osh-tekk are supposed to be dead, that also makes little to no sense.


Kotal Kahn's concept art says that the blue skin is actually body paint. You can see this in game if you look at him during a close up, his skin is covered in a very paint-like texture. I prefer him blue, though.

I'm not sure on that second issue though.
Avatar
KenshiMaster16
04/18/2015 09:00 AM (UTC)
0
Cages_Shades Wrote:
The comics ARE canon, BUT the games story was made first

Its the comics writers fault not NRS, but i'm sure the comic writers didnt know every dialogue of the game.


This.
Avatar
RainReptile
04/18/2015 12:15 PM (UTC)
0
The errors really bugged me. Was it that hard for Vogel and Kittelston to compare notes?
Avatar
Onaga
04/18/2015 12:47 PM (UTC)
0
RainReptile Wrote:
The errors really bugged me. Was it that hard for Vogel and Kittelston to compare notes?


Seems as though it is hard for Vogel to compare notes period. What with all the retconning he continues to do like oh say with the Tarkata! God damn it Vogel....
Avatar
theJudicator
Avatar
About Me

ain't nobody got time fo sigs

04/18/2015 03:19 PM (UTC)
0
Sekktor Wrote:
the comics aren't canon, at all. no relative to the MKX game whatsoever.


They are, but at this point... they don't seem to be...
Avatar
James_Sunderland
Avatar
About Me

Second fan of "The Lady in Green...err Turquoise, no Gold?"

04/18/2015 03:41 PM (UTC)
0
I think they're retconning the purple sky thing as a way for them to be acknowledged as a more mature game. I aksp think they're trying to engrain it in our minds that it never existed.

Like KJ said, "Dont believe everything you read on the internet."
Avatar
SpellcraftQuill
04/18/2015 03:44 PM (UTC)
0
I think it went away as soon as Kahn was out of the picture.
Pages: 2
Discord
Twitch
Twitter
YouTube
Facebook
Privacy Policy
© 1998-2024 Shadow Knight Media, LLC. All rights reserved. Mortal Kombat, the dragon logo and all character names are trademarks and copyright of Warner Bros. Entertainment Inc.